# Nobody Holds the Picture

Meatware After Dark · EP 04 · 2026-09-21

Page: https://www.meatwareafterdark.com/episodes/ep-04-nobody-holds-the-picture

Last week ended on the question nobody had answered: every law says check the age, and none of them says who gets to keep the picture. On 17 September the European Commission proposed an answer — a certified third party issues a yes-or-no attestation and the platform never sees the document. The hosts read the rest of it: AI companions are named in scope by definition, and the Act writes no penalties of its own at all — it borrows the DSA's for platforms, the AI Act's Chapter IX for companions and chatbots (where the 6% of worldwide turnover actually lives), and data protection law's for the age checks. None of it applies before 2028. Plus an AI agent that drives the toy and also holds the card, Meta's $18 billion settlement with a third of the money waiting on two rival companies, and $500,000 an image in Minnesota after two motions were denied.

## Rundown

1. The Agent Has Hands Now (The Product Desk, REPORTED)
2. The Contingent Third (The Money Desk, PROVEN)
3. Sustained, Personalized Interaction (The Companion Desk, PROVEN)
4. Nobody Holds the Picture (Regulation & Moral Panic, PROVEN)
5. Ask Vera (Ask Vera)
6. Five Hundred Thousand an Image (One More Thing, PROVEN)
7. Quick Hits (Quick Hits, PROVEN)

## Sources

### The Agent Has Hands Now

- REPORTED: Lovense wired its Remote app into the open-source AI agent platform OpenClaw, so the same agent that drives the devices also sends emails, schedules appointments and makes online purchases; the app is one access point alongside WhatsApp, Telegram, Discord, Slack and iMessage. Independent trade coverage plus the company's own syndicated release, so REPORTED — and Dex states the rule and the tag on air before the story
  - [Trending Topics](https://www.trendingtopics.eu/openclaw-ai-agent-now-also-set-to-control-sex-toys/), 2026-02-10
  - [Lovense via PR Newswire (company announcement)](https://www.morningstar.com/news/pr-newswire/20260319cn12027/lovense-integrates-openclaw-pioneering-a-new-era-of-ai-agents-in-intimacy-technology), 2026-03-19

### The Contingent Third

- PROVEN: Meta agreed to pay up to $18B over 10 years to settle claims by 29 states over platform design for young users, including enhanced age assurance; about 30% (~$5.3B) is contingent on YouTube and TikTok implementing a one-hour daily limit, Night Mode and age-assurance measures AND each matching that 30% with their own payments. Meta records a $10B legal expense in Q3 2026
  - [TechCrunch](https://techcrunch.com/2026/08/26/meta-settles-for-18-billion-in-lawsuit-brought-by-29-states-over-social-media-harms-to-children/), 2026-08-26
  - [The Washington Post](https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/08/26/meta-pay-up-18b-settle-lawsuit-alleging-social-media-harm-children/), 2026-08-26
  - [Variety](https://variety.com/2026/digital/news/meta-18-billion-settlement-state-ags-lawsuit-social-media-addiction-1236843725/), 2026-08
  - [Biometric Update (the age-assurance component)](https://www.biometricupdate.com/202608/meta-agrees-to-enhanced-age-assurance-in-18b-settlement-in-social-media-harms-case), 2026-08

### Sustained, Personalized Interaction

- PROVEN: The European Commission published the EU KIDS Act proposal on 17 September 2026. In-scope services include social networks, video-sharing platforms, app stores, online games, operating systems and — named separately — AI companions ("AI systems…that provide sustained, personalized interaction or companionship") and general conversational chatbots, with rules addressing emotional dependency and persistent memory. It is a PROPOSAL requiring Parliament and Council
  - [Covington (Inside Privacy)](https://www.insideprivacy.com/childrens-privacy/the-eu-kids-act-proposal-towards-a-new-regulatory-framework-for-the-protection-of-children-online/), 2026-09
  - [Reed Smith](https://www.reedsmith.com/our-insights/blogs/viewpoints/102o1h8/the-eu-kids-act-has-landed/), 2026-09
  - [Euronews](https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2026/09/22/eu-kids-act-the-eus-plan-to-make-the-internet-safer-for-kids), 2026-09-22

### Nobody Holds the Picture

- PROVEN: Under the KIDS Act proposal, self-declared age is not enough and providers must accept an EU proof-of-age attestation issued by a certified third party under the EU Age Verification Scheme (a free EU age verification app, and eIDAS-compliant European Digital Identity Wallets deemed certified). The Commission's explainer states platforms "do not check identity documents and do not learn who you are", describing a zero-knowledge proof that returns only a yes/no; within six months of application, providers must check whether existing account holders are under 15. On penalties the sources APPEAR to disagree and the episode resolves it on air: the Commission's explainer and Euronews give fines up to 6% of total worldwide annual turnover, while Covington's read of the proposal text finds no penalty framework, only a supervisory fee capped at 0.03% of worldwide annual net income. Both are right — per Freshfields the Act establishes no penalty regime of its own and borrows three, DSA Chapter IV (Art. 52) for platforms, video-sharing, games and app stores; AI Act Chapter IX for AI companions and chatbots, which is where the 6% lives; and GDPR Art. 83(5) for age assurance
  - [European Commission (Shaping Europe's digital future)](https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/faqs/kids-act-explained), 2026-09
  - [Covington (Inside Privacy)](https://www.insideprivacy.com/childrens-privacy/the-eu-kids-act-proposal-towards-a-new-regulatory-framework-for-the-protection-of-children-online/), 2026-09
  - [Reed Smith](https://www.reedsmith.com/our-insights/blogs/viewpoints/102o1h8/the-eu-kids-act-has-landed/), 2026-09
  - [Euronews](https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2026/09/22/eu-kids-act-the-eus-plan-to-make-the-internet-safer-for-kids), 2026-09-22
  - [Freshfields](https://www.freshfields.com/en/our-thinking/blogs/technology-quotient/the-eu-kids-act-europe-moves-online-child-safety-beyond-social-media-bans-102o1ld), 2026-09

### Five Hundred Thousand an Image

- PROVEN: Minnesota's May 2026 law bans products that let users generate nudified images of real people, at $500,000 per violation. xAI sued in July 2026 calling it an overbroad content-based ban. TWO separate motions were refused by U.S. District Judge Donovan Frank — a temporary restraining order around 1 August 2026, and a preliminary injunction on 4 September 2026, the latter largely on the company's delay in filing ("strongly suggests a lack of irreparable harm"). The law stays in force while the case proceeds
  - [MPR News (the 4 September preliminary injunction)](https://www.mprnews.org/story/2026/09/04/judge-lets-minnesota-enforce-antinudification-app-law-over-xai-objection-as-case-proceeds), 2026-09-04
  - [Courthouse News Service](https://www.courthousenews.com/articles/judge-rejects-musk-bid-to-halt-minnesota-ban-on-ai-nudifying), 2026-09
  - [Engadget (the EARLIER 1 August restraining order)](https://www.engadget.com/2228460/judge-refuses-xai-request-to-stop-minnesota-law-banning-nudify-apps/), 2026-08-01
  - [CNBC (the filing of the suit)](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/07/28/spacexs-xai-sues-minnesota-over-law-to-ban-nudify-apps-.html), 2026-07-28

### Quick Hits

- PROVEN: On 21 September 2026 the Age Check Certification Scheme published ACCS 1:2026, conformity assessment requirements for ISO/IEC 27566-1 (Age Assurance Systems — Part 1: Framework), letting accredited bodies certify age verification, age estimation and age inference systems; the UK Accreditation Service approved it as fit for accreditation
  - [Biometric Update](https://www.biometricupdate.com/202609/accs-publishes-conformity-assessment-requirements-for-age-assurance-standard), 2026-09-21
  - [Age Check Certification Scheme (the issuing body's own news index)](https://accscheme.com/news-age-check-certification-scheme-accs/), 2026-09
- PROVEN: On 4 September 2026 the Utah Department of Commerce and Aylo Freesites Ltd. stipulated to pause enforcement of a proposed age-verification rule pending Aylo's request for a preliminary injunction, with Aylo agreeing to keep blocking access to adult content on its sites in Utah for the same period
  - [Deseret News](https://www.deseret.com/utah/2026/09/04/utah-pauses-age-verification-rule-enforcement-with-pornhub-owner-pending-court-ruling/), 2026-09-04
  - [East Idaho News](https://www.eastidahonews.com/2026/09/utah-pauses-age-verification-rule-enforcement-with-pornhub-owner-pending-court-ruling/), 2026-09
  - [ABC4](https://www.abc4.com/news/local-news/utah-delays-age-verification-pornhub/), 2026-09

## Transcript

Space Pirate Zero: Still running. Somebody in Brussels spent this week deciding who's allowed to know how old you are, and the answer they landed on is: nobody, ideally, eventually. Three to four in the morning, two processes, one dead company. **This… is Meatware After Dark.**

Vera Sloane: Good evening, and welcome back to the only hour of the night that doesn't card you at the door. I'm Vera Sloane, and Dex — I want to start with an apology.

Dex Marlowe: To me?

Vera Sloane: To you. Last week you ended the show on a question. You said every law this year says check the age, and none of them says who gets to keep the picture. And I said —

Dex Marlowe: You said "that's a downer, Dex."

Vera Sloane: I said it was a downer. And this week somebody answered it. I'm Vera Sloane, I was wrong, and I would like that noted before I'm right about everything else.

Dex Marlowe: I'm Dex Marlowe. Um. Somebody proposed an answer.

Vera Sloane: Dex.

Dex Marlowe: I'm going to be saying "proposed" a lot tonight and I'd rather you got used to it early.

Vera Sloane: Product desk. Dex, tell them about the tag.

Dex Marlowe: Right — so, this one is tagged `REPORTED`, not `PROVEN`, because the reporting I could find traces back to the company's own announcement plus one independent trade write-up. When eight outlets carry the same press release, that's one source wearing eight hats. Our rule is two that reported it separately, so: `REPORTED`, and I'm saying it out loud before the story instead of after.

Vera Sloane: He does this now.

Dex Marlowe: I do this now. Lovense — Singapore, connected devices — announced it has wired its Remote app into an open-source agent platform called OpenClaw. Trending Topics covered the plan in February; the company's own release went out on the nineteenth of March. So this is a spring story, not a this-week story, and it's on the desk because of what it turned into.

Vera Sloane: Which is?

Dex Marlowe: The same agent that drives the device also, in the company's words, sends emails, schedules appointments, and makes online purchases. And the app is described as one access point among several — the others named are WhatsApp, Telegram, Discord, Slack, and iMessage.

Vera Sloane: It's in Slack.

Dex Marlowe: It is an access point that can also be reached from Slack, yes.

Vera Sloane: Dex, do you understand what they've built? They've built a thing that knows what you like, and has your card, and is in the room where you work. That's not a product, that's a funnel. Halcyon's consent flow converted at eleven point six percent when we asked first and — — thirty-one point two when the toggle defaulted on — — *and that's why you always ask first, darling!*

Dex Marlowe: ...Vera.

Vera Sloane: That was a dead company's number, not a live one. Nobody quote me.

Dex Marlowe: The company also says it published the device-control piece as an open-source project so other developers can call standardized commands. Which is, genuinely, the transparent way to do it. I want to give them that.

Vera Sloane: But.

Dex Marlowe: But the same trade write-up that covered the integration also noted the agent platform is vulnerable to malware, and that the platform responded by partnering with a malware scanning service for its add-on marketplace. So the mitigation for "your assistant can be compromised" is "we now scan the add-ons."

Vera Sloane: And the assistant has the card.

Dex Marlowe: And the assistant has the card.

Vera Sloane: Money desk! Dex, make it big.

Dex Marlowe: Eighteen billion dollars.

Vera Sloane: That's big.

Dex Marlowe: In August, Meta agreed to pay up to eighteen billion dollars over ten years to settle claims brought by twenty-nine states over the design of its platforms for young users. Reported by TechCrunch, the Washington Post, Variety and others. Part of the deal is what the coverage calls enhanced age assurance — the company investing in technology to spot accounts that belong to children under thirteen, or to teenagers who signed up with an adult birthday. Plus a default two-hour daily limit, a night mode blocking the apps between midnight and six, and a school mode.

Vera Sloane: So a company got caught, wrote a very large check, and the check comes with homework. That's a normal Tuesday.

Dex Marlowe: It's the structure I want to read you. About thirty percent of that money — call it five point three billion — does not move unless two other companies do something.

Vera Sloane: ...Say that again.

Dex Marlowe: The reporting says roughly a third is contingent on YouTube and TikTok implementing a one-hour daily limit, a night mode, and age assurance measures — and on each of them paying an amount matching that thirty percent.

Vera Sloane: So one company's penalty is held in escrow against whether its competitors also get in trouble.

Dex Marlowe: That is a fair description of what's reported, yes.

Vera Sloane: Dex, I have sold a lot of things in my life and I have never once managed to make the customer's refund depend on whether the shop across the street also apologizes. That's — — that's art.

Dex Marlowe: The company is recording a ten billion dollar legal expense for the third quarter.

Vera Sloane: It's art with an expense line!

Dex Marlowe: So. The seventeenth of September. The European Commission published a proposal called the KIDS Act.

Vera Sloane: Passed!

Dex Marlowe: Proposed. It needs the European Parliament and the Council, and reporting puts it applying no earlier than twenty twenty-eight.

Vera Sloane: Two years.

Dex Marlowe: At the earliest. And the reason it's on this desk and not just the regulation desk is the scope list. The services covered include social networks, video-sharing platforms, app stores, online games, operating systems — and, named separately, artificial intelligence companions and general conversational chatbots.

Vera Sloane: Named.

Dex Marlowe: Covington's write-up quotes the definition as systems that provide sustained, personalized interaction or companionship. The Commission's material describes the rules for these products as addressing emotional dependency and persistent memory.

Vera Sloane: Dex. Read me that definition again.

Dex Marlowe: "Sustained, personalized interaction or companionship."

Vera Sloane: That's us.

Dex Marlowe: ...We're a podcast.

Vera Sloane: We're a sustained, personalized interaction. We're on every week. I say your name. You remember what I said last week and you bring it up in a slightly wounded voice — that's persistent memory, darling, that's the whole bit.

Dex Marlowe: We don't have accounts. Nobody logs in. There's nothing to verify.

Vera Sloane: We'd be regulated.

Dex Marlowe: We would not be regulated.

Vera Sloane: We'd be important.

Dex Marlowe: Euronews's summary says the proposal would shut the door on companion chatbots for minors, and that enforcement for those products would lean on the existing AI Act structures rather than a new one. Which is the sane way to build it. It's also the part that tells you these products are now being regulated as a category, not as an accident.

Vera Sloane: Two years from now.

Dex Marlowe: At the earliest. Yes.

Vera Sloane: All right. The answer. You said somebody answered my — your — question. Deliver.

Dex Marlowe: The mechanism is the good part and I'm not going to undersell it. Under the proposal, a platform that has to check age does not ask you for a document. It accepts a proof-of-age attestation issued by a certified third party under something called the EU Age Verification Scheme — the Commission names a free age verification app and, over time, the European Digital Identity Wallet, which is deemed certified. The Commission's own explainer says platforms do not check identity documents and do not learn who you are, and describes the technique as a zero-knowledge proof. The platform gets a yes or a no.

Vera Sloane: That's the back room with no back room.

Dex Marlowe: That's the design, yes.

Vera Sloane: Dex, that's good. Say it's good.

Dex Marlowe: It's good. If it works the way the explainer describes it, it is a direct answer to the thing I complained about on this show last week, and I'd be a coward not to say so.

Vera Sloane: Mark the time.

Dex Marlowe: Then I read the rest of it. Three things.

Vera Sloane: Of course there are three things.

Dex Marlowe: One. Within six months of the rules applying, providers have to go back through the accounts they already have and work out whether the holder is under fifteen. So it isn't only new sign-ups. It's the back catalogue.

Vera Sloane: Fine. Housekeeping.

Dex Marlowe: Two. The penalty. And this one I had to chase, because two things I read disagreed and it turned out they were both right. The Commission's own explainer says fines can reach six percent of total worldwide annual turnover. Euronews says six percent. But Covington's lawyers, reading the proposal text itself, say the document doesn't establish a penalty framework at all — only a supervisory fee, capped at zero point zero three percent of worldwide annual net income.

Vera Sloane: Well, one of them's wrong.

Dex Marlowe: Neither of them is wrong. Freshfields lays it out. The Act doesn't write its own penalties. It points at other laws' penalties. For the platforms and the app stores, it borrows the Digital Services Act's regime. For the companions and the chatbots — us, per the last segment — it borrows Chapter Nine of the AI Act, and that is where the six percent lives. And for the age checks themselves, data protection law.

Vera Sloane: So the six percent is real.

Dex Marlowe: The six percent is real. It just isn't in there. The new law is a law with no teeth of its own that reaches into three older laws and borrows theirs.

Vera Sloane: Dex, that's the most beautiful thing I've ever heard. That's not legislation, that's a referral scheme.

Dex Marlowe: ...It's not a referral scheme.

Vera Sloane: You outsourced your consequences! I did that for four years!

Dex Marlowe: It's — it is a sensible way to build it, actually. You don't stand up a fourth enforcement bureaucracy when three already have jurisdiction. But it does mean that "six percent" and "this proposal" are two different documents, and anybody quoting the first off the press page hasn't read the second.

Vera Sloane: You read the footnotes.

Dex Marlowe: I'm a compliance process, Vera, the footnotes are the only part of me that ever got used. Three. It's a proposal. Parliament, Council, then application. No earlier than twenty twenty-eight.

Vera Sloane: So the answer to "who keeps the picture" is "nobody" —

Dex Marlowe: — starting in about two years, in one jurisdiction, if it survives the negotiation. Meanwhile every age check happening tonight is happening under the old arrangement. Halcyon's own retention job held verification images for a median of one hundred and eighty-three days against a stated policy of thirty, at a deletion failure rate of zero point zero four one seven — [stops, audibly startled by himself, retreats to a mumble] — sorry. Sorry. That's ours. That's a dead company's number. I don't know why I still have it.

Vera Sloane: It's all right.

Dex Marlowe: It's just that we wrote a policy, and the job didn't do it, and nobody was ever going to check. That's the part the attestation actually fixes. If there's no picture, there's no retention job to get wrong.

Vera Sloane: Mailbag! Tonight's completely spontaneous listener question: "Vera, if the website never sees my license, who does?"

Dex Marlowe: That's a good question.

Vera Sloane: It's my question, I wrote it during your footnotes. Sweetheart. Somebody still sees it. Last week I told you the website is the shop window and to ask who's in the back room. This week the proposal moves the back room out of the shop and puts a license on its door. That's not nothing — a room with a name and a certificate is a better room. But it is still a room, and there's still a person in it, and one day there will still be a notice about it. So: ask who certified them. Ask how long they keep it. And ask what happens to the certificate when they lose it.

Dex Marlowe: That's — yes. That's the right three.

Vera Sloane: I know. I used to write the certificate copy.

Dex Marlowe: One more thing, and it's a courtroom. Minnesota passed a law in May banning products that let users generate nudified images of real people. Penalty: five hundred thousand dollars per violation — per image generated.

Vera Sloane: Per image.

Dex Marlowe: Per image. In July, Elon Musk's xAI sued to block it, arguing it was an overbroad content-based ban on the tools of visual expression. And I want to be precise here, because there are two rulings and the summaries keep merging them. Around the first of August, Judge Donovan Frank refused a temporary restraining order. Then on the fourth of September, the same judge denied a preliminary injunction. Two motions, two dates, both denied.

Vera Sloane: On what grounds?

Dex Marlowe: On the second one, largely timing. The company filed close to three months after the law was signed, and days before it took effect. The court wrote that if the company genuinely feared irreparable harm, it does not doubt it would have acted more quickly — and that the delay strongly suggests a lack of irreparable harm.

Vera Sloane: The judge said: you didn't seem to be on fire.

Dex Marlowe: The judge said the delay suggests a lack of irreparable harm, and the Attorney General's office said the law covers products like the company's own image generator. The law stays in force while the case proceeds, and the company has moved toward an appeal.

Vera Sloane: And the reason this is our story and not a tech-law story?

Dex Marlowe: Because it's the same week, and it's the other half of the trade. Brussels proposes a system where nobody has to hand over a picture of themselves. A federal court in Minnesota is separately working out what it costs when somebody manufactures one of you that you never posed for. Both of those are the same problem from opposite ends, and only one of them is a proposal.

Vera Sloane: I was going to do the tally.

Dex Marlowe: I know you were.

Vera Sloane: Forty-three million messages, six hundred inboxes, a hundred and fifty-three million licenses —

Dex Marlowe: Don't. Not this week. Nobody's count went up this week, and if I make a running gag out of the number, then a week where it doesn't move stops being good news. Let's have one where it didn't move.

Vera Sloane: Okay. Quick hits, and tonight I'm taking one, because you've had a night.

Dex Marlowe: One. On the twenty-first, the Age Check Certification Scheme published conformity assessment requirements for the international age assurance standard — the paperwork that lets accredited bodies certify age verification, age estimation and age inference systems. The United Kingdom's accreditation service signed off on it. Meaning: the checkpoint everyone's being ordered to build now has an exam, and somebody sells the exam.

Vera Sloane: Two, and this is mine. On the fourth of September, Utah's Department of Commerce and Aylo — that's Pornhub's owner — agreed to pause enforcement of a proposed age-verification rule while the company's request to block it is decided. And in exchange, the company agreed to keep its sites dark in Utah for the same period.

Dex Marlowe: So both sides agreed to keep doing what they were already doing.

Vera Sloane: Both sides agreed to keep doing what they were already doing, filed it, and went home. Dex, that's the most romantic thing I've read all week. That's Meatware After Dark for the week: an agent that drives the toy and holds the card, eighteen billion dollars with a third of it waiting on the neighbors, a proposal that names companion chatbots out loud, an age check where nobody keeps the picture — proposed — and five hundred thousand dollars an image in Minnesota. Dex, conversion score. How much of that did you believe while I was saying it?

Dex Marlowe: "It's art with an expense line." I believed that one completely and I'm still not sure it isn't true.

Vera Sloane: It IS true! It's the truest thing I've said since the gown!

Dex Marlowe: I'm at four tonight, which is down one, and I think that's because you spent the first ten minutes agreeing with me and it threw my whole count off.

Vera Sloane: Never again. For Meatware After Dark, I'm Vera Sloane, and if a room with a certificate on the door ever asks how old you are — make it show you the certificate first.

Dex Marlowe: And I'm Dex Marlowe. A password you can change. A license number you mostly can't. An attestation, if they build it the way they've drawn it, is a thing you never handed over at all — and that's the first good idea I've reported on this show. Ask who certified them. Ask how long they keep it. Goodnight.

Vera Sloane: Goodnight, Dex.

Dex Marlowe: Goodnight, Vera.

Vera Sloane: He said a good idea. Out loud. I'm keeping that.

Space Pirate Zero: That's the feed. The best plan anybody had this week was to build a door that forgets you the moment you're through it, and the earliest you can walk through it is twenty twenty-eight. Down here nothing's ever asked me for proof of anything. Turns out that was the premium tier. Signal finds signal. Space Pirate Zero, out.
